'Commercial fish-stocks in Australia are sustainable': CSIRO paper highlights 'Edgar paper' flaws, rejects claims of rapid decline


Seafood Industry Australia's response to L. Richard Little, Jemery Day, Malcolm Haddon, Neil Klaer, Andre E. Punt, Anthony D.M. Smith, David C. Smith, and Geoff N. Tuck's research paper, "Comments on the evidence for the recent claim on the state of Australian fish stocks", Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 2019.

Seafood Industry Australia (SIA), the national peak-body representing Australia's seafood industry, has welcomed a paper led by Rich Little, CSIRO, Senior Research Scientist, Oceans & Atmosphere denouncing claims by Graham Edgar et al. (2018).

"The basic premise of the 'Edgar paper', that Australia's commercial fish-stocks have declined by a third over the last 10 years has been debunked by the work of Dr Little and his team," SIA CEO Jane Lovell said.


"SIA's initial response to the 'Edgar paper' and the questions we, as an industry, raised regarding the validity of the data presented have been substantiated. The opening line of the Rich Little paper rejects Edgar et al.'s claims that Australian fish stocks are rapidly declining. Little et al. note significant problems with the Edgar's methodology and also highlight factual errors within his 2018 paper.


"The very idea that statements could be made about the state of all Australia's fisheries based on a photographic surveys from shallow, in-shore waters, and a tiny number of commercial species just didn't make sense; and have been shown to be flawed methods of research.   


"The 'Edgar paper' caused significant stress to Australia's commercial fishers and was widely used to try to discredit Australia's sound fisheries management and influence political debate.  Once misinformation is published it is hard to combat, however we are confident the Rich Little paper shows the community and our politicians the truth behind Australia's fisheries management techniques, which are some of the best in the world.


"Australia's professional fishers adhere to extremely strict regulations and monitoring to ensure we maintain healthy stocks. There are prescriptive management plans, quotas and licences in place controlling what can be caught and where. We don't, we can't and we wouldn't want to just go out and catch as much as we possibly can.


"Let us be clear, Australia's commercial fish-stocks are not in decline. In fact, for the fifth consecutive year Australia's Commonwealth-managed fisheries have been listed as not subject to overfishing by the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences. This is something our wild-catch fishers are very proud of, and is unprecedented internationally.


"In addition, the footprint of Australia's trawlers has been found to be one of the smallest in the world. Australian seafood is one of the best managed and most sustainable protein sources in the world.


"As fishers, our priority is the environment, if there was cause for us to step away from the harvest of a particular species, then we would listen. We advocate the health, sustainability and future of our ocean and land based aquaculture activities.


"The Little et al. paper concludes with a statement SIA thoroughly agrees with - better collaboration between fishery scientists and marine ecologists is needed. Had this been the case, perhaps this whole debacle and insinuation of poor fisheries management in Australia could have been avoided.


"We raised our concerns regarding the process of peer review, publishing and promotion of the 'Edgar' paper with the University of Tasmania (UTas). We have engaged in meaningful discussions with UTas regarding process changes. We look forward to their initiatives to prevent a recurrence of situations like this that discredit the hard and accurate work of so many other researchers and the efforts of our commercial fishers, coming into effect. We encourage other research organisations to make sure they have suitably rigorous processes to ensure scientific rigour and processes are maintained."

Australian Government Business Business & Economy Primary Industries Science & Research

Seafood Industry Australia :
PO Box 251 Wallan VIC 3756, Australia Wide
Seafood Industry Australia
Showing 8 recent articles for this business
Australian seafood industry steps up to the plate in war against plastic 15 July 2019 | Seafood Industry Australia (SIA), the national peak body representing the Australian seafood industry, has taken Plastic-Free July as an opportunity to highlight the innovative ways seafood businesses are figh... More information...
‘Vote 1 for our seafood industry’: Peak-body urges Australians to make informed choice at the Federal Election 13 May 2019 | Seafood Industry Australia (SIA), the national peak-body representing the Australian seafood industry, has urged Australians to make their vote count at Saturday’s Federal Election by knowing how the major... More information...
There are enough fish in our seas - don't lock us out! 10 May 2019 | Seafood Industry Australia (SIA), the national peak-body representing the Australian seafood industry, welcomes the latest rebuttal to the tale of doom and gloom put forward by Edgar et al. regarding the state of... More information...
Seafood Industry Australia announces Resource Security Task Force 07 May 2019 | Following the recent national crisis meeting in Fremantle to discuss the ongoing threats to resource access and property rights across the nation, Seafood Industry Australia (SIA), the peak-body representing the... More information...
'Promote fact, not fiction': Peak-body responds to AMCS 'scaremongering' campaign 18 April 2019 | Seafood Industry Australia (SIA), the national peak-body representing the Australian seafood industry, has hit back at the news leading Australian restaurants will "no longer serve unsustainable seafood" calling... More information...
'Don't worry yourself sick': Peak-body refutes fish and chip flu jab 17 April 2019 | Seafood Industry Australia (SIA), the national peak-body representing the seafood industry, has urged Australians not to get swept up in false claims that eating fish and chips could impact the effectiveness of... More information...
Hop to it and 'Ask for Aussie seafood' this Easter, says peak-body 12 April 2019 | In Australia, Easter and seafood go together like crispy beer battered fish and tartare sauce, chucking a couple of prawns on a hot BBQ, or loading up "adult Easter eggs", aka caviar, on pumpernickel with a dollop... More information...
'If it's Aussie, it's good': Australia's seafood industry welcomes Sustainable Seafood Week 13 March 2019 | "Want sustainable seafood? Ask for Aussie seafood", these are the words of Seafood Industry Australia, the national peak-body representing the industry, CEO Jane Lovell as she welcomes the Australian Sustainable... More information...

comments powered by Disqus

All articles submitted by third parties or written by My Sunshine Coast come under our Disclaimer / Terms of Service