Fears Coronavirus could lead to human rights abuses

Published:

UNSW's Professor Anthony Zwi says Australia needs to think seriously about how the nation responds now that the Coronavirus pandemic has been officially declared.

Under the Biosecurity Act (2015), individuals who pose an infectious diseases risk to the community can be forcibly detained or isolated.

The global policy and health expert was interviewed after disturbing images surfaced on social media of people in China being dragged screaming into vans and of homes being welded shut.

He says many of China's responses in trying to contain the virus have been praised by the World Health Organisation but adds that there have also been "some worrying and horrific scenes."  

He says that while these photos and videos are difficult to verify, there is also evidence of efforts taken in China against health workers and journalists who sought to warn the community and authorities of the impending epidemic.

"Efforts to silence health workers and other citizens documenting inadequacies or heavy-handed state responses are very troubling," he says.

Professor Zwi says all countries, including Australia, should refer to the UN Siracusa Principles (1981) which weigh-up individual rights against efforts to contain a public emergency or major threat such as a pandemic.  

He says the Principles state that the measures applied have to be strictly necessary.

"So, in some cases, while it may be important to separate people from the general community or limit movement into or out of certain areas, this needs to be undertaken through the least intrusive or restrictive means available," Prof. Zwi says.

"The Siracusa Principles reinforce that public health measures should not be arbitrary, discriminatory and should be subject to review. At key points we will need to take a step back and question how our societies and systems are managing this crisis."

He says we need to ask if the response is proportionate; are we keeping the ethical principles that should frame our actions front-of-mind; are our systems and responses humane?

He says if people have to be quarantined in their homes, then they should be monitored, supported, provided with health care and given access to services if they become more ill.

Even though the government's Coronavirus response plan includes key aspects of the Siracusa guidelines, Prof. Zwi says it is important to reinforce on the ground that officials do not take an authoritarian or "top-down" approach.

"The human rights abuses that can occur in such situations can be extreme and unacceptable," he says.

He urges people "not to panic" but to listen to "trusted public health officials" and to follow their advice.

Professor Zwi is confident Australia is well-equipped to respond to COVID-19.

"But as COVID-19 continues to spread globally," Prof. Zwi says, "the pressures on front-line staff, the health system, communities, and budgets will increase."

"And we need to continuously examine and respond to communities and groups most at risk – older people, those with chronic conditions or in long term care facilities – but also front-line workers, migrant and Indigenous communities."

Professor Zwi is concerned that many vulnerable groups may not only be susceptible to the viral infection itself, but also to the knock-on impacts of economic decline, xenophobia and racism, which in some cases may reflect "historical distrust of authorities."

"All communities and sectors – such as health, education, business, trade unions, and Indigenous people – across Australia, need to be involved in how responses are shaped to ensure that they are consultative, ethical, and act in solidarity with those affected," he says.

He argues for the need to "maintain or develop effective channels of communication and to treat all with dignity."  

 
Australian Government Community Equality Health & Wellness Law & Safety Political
Social:   

Privately Submitted Article or Event :
See Above Article or Event for Address, Sunshine Coast Wide
Privately Submitted Article or Event
Showing 10+ recent articles for this business
Australian Company offers thousands of Free Hand Sanitisers 27 March 2020 | National Online Auction Company Lloyds Auctions is offering thousands of free sanitisation products with free shipping Nationwide. More information...
Whole of population telehealth welcomed 30 March 2020 | The National Rural Health Alliance, the peak body for rural and remote health in Australia, welcomed the Australian Government's expansion of telehealth services which starts today. More information...
Muslims Down Under launch a new website 30 March 2020 | Muslims Down Under is a platform that enables reflection and engagement by promoting intellectual conversation and open dialogue. The group is well known for their complimentary 'Coffee and Islam' service in all... More information...
Caravan Parks stand ready to assist with quarantining arrivals 27 March 2020 | Caravan Industry Association of Australia says caravan parks stand ready to assist with the quarantining of arrivals from Australia's international airports as mandated by Prime Minister Scott Morrison this... More information...
The first ‘Charities Crisis Cabinet’ to meet on Tuesday 27 March 2020 | CCA is pleased to announce the establishment of the Charities Crisis Cabinet. The Cabinet will be seeking to enable as many charities as possible to survive through this pandemic and contribute to building... More information...
Camp at Home Heroes: Fun & education for staying home this Easter 27 March 2020 | Easter travel is off and rightly so, but you don't have to cancel your family camping experience! More information...
Caravan Industry calls for cabin accommodation exemption 26 March 2020 | Caravan Industry Association of Australia (CIAA) is calling on State Governments to review sweeping orders in some states forcing caravan park closures that will see self-contained cabin accommodation ideally... More information...
Consumers warned about scams involving the newly-announced early-release super measures. 26 March 2020 | The Australian Institute of Superannuation Trustees (AIST) is aware that unscrupulous operators have already begun targeting super fund members and offering to assist them in taking up the new early release super... More information...
Fake news checklist to fight against COVID-19 misinformation 26 March 2020 | Fake information about coronavirus is diverting previous resources away from Australia's fight against COVID-19, says Responsible Technology Australia as it launches a checklist for social media users to spot fake... More information...
Telehealth expansion welcomed but more needs to be done 26 March 2020 | The National Rural Health Alliance, the peak body for rural and remote health in Australia, has welcomed the Australian Government's expansion of telehealth Medicare item numbers but has called for access to be... More information...


comments powered by Disqus

All articles submitted by third parties or written by My Sunshine Coast come under our Disclaimer / Terms of Service