Greenpeace 'scary monsters' report has zero credibility

Published: Comments:

This is an archived copy of an article. It is online for informational purposes only.
Social:   

Today’s latest comic book from Greenpeace on the growth prospects of the Queensland coal industry has zero credibility, according to the state's peak minerals and energy industry body.

'Not satisfied with their February 2012 prediction that Queensland would be exporting 944 million tonnes of coal by 2020, Greenpeace’s 'scary monsters' unit has lifted their fanciful prediction to 1056 million tonnes of coal exports from Queensland ports,' said Chief Executive of the Queensland Resources Council Michael Roche.

Mr Roche said that coal exports from Queensland over the 13 years to 2011-12 grew by a compound average growth rate of 4.4 percent, from 94 million tonnes to 165 million tonnes, and that in the past five years, growth had been only 1.5 percent per annum (from 153 million tonnes to 165 million tonnes).

'So after the Queensland coal industry has managed to grow exports by a grand total of 71 million tonnes in the past 13 years, Greenpeace would have people believe that coal exports will grow by a further 891 million tonnes over the next decade.

'Put another way, Greenpeace has the Queensland coal industry growing more than six fold.

'It is simply not going to happen.'

Mr Roche pointed out that the most up-to-date credible forecasts for Queensland coal exports come from the federal government’s Bureau of Resource and Energy Economics (BREE) in its July 2012 report 'Australian Bulk Commodity Exports and Infrastructure – outlook to 2025.

'According to BREE the high-range outlook for coal exports for Queensland by 2020 is 327 million tonnes and a mid-range figure would be 301 million tonnes.

'Who is the public to believe—the independent experts at BREE or the people from the scary monsters unit at Greenpeace, an organisation committed to shutting down the Australian coal industry?'

Mr Roche said that because the Greenpeace coal export prediction had zero credibility, it followed that their shipping volume figures were similarly fanciful.

Mr Roche said that an independent Great Barrier Reef shipping study to be published in the very near future would put a lie to the Greenpeace predictions for shipping movements in the Great Barrier Reef area.

This study has been prepared as part of the comprehensive industry-led cumulative impact assessment study of proposed coal port development at Abbott Point.

 
Queensland Resources Council (QRC) :
Level 13, 133 Mary Street, Brisbane
07 3295 9560
07 3295 9560
Queensland Resources Council (QRC)



Social:   
comments powered by Disqus

All articles submitted by third parties or written by My Sunshine Coast come under our Disclaimer / Terms of Service