Landmark High Court trial to test if Constitutional 'aliens' power applies to Aboriginal Australians

Published: Comments:
Australian Government Community Indigenous & Heritage Law & Safety


Tomorrow a landmark trial will be held in the High Court of Australia to determine an important threshold question as to whether Aboriginal Australians can be considered an 'alien' under the Constitution and, as a result, be deported following a serious criminal conviction.

The special case is being brought on behalf of Aboriginal Australian men, Daniel Love and Brendan Thoms. It will be argued that both men are Australian nationals because they are Aboriginal people who, although born overseas, are not aliens under the Constitution.
Mr Love was born in Papua New Guinea. His father was a natural born Australian citizen and Aboriginal Australian. Mr Thoms was born in New Zealand. Mr Thoms' mother is an Australian citizen and an Aboriginal Australian woman. Both men have lived in Australia since they were young boys. Both have an extensive Aboriginal Australian heritage. Both have children who are Australian citizens and identify as Aboriginal Australian. Mr Thoms also is a native title holder.
Both were convicted of criminal offences and served time in prison. At the conclusion of their sentences last year, both men had their visas revoked and were taken to immigration detention in Brisbane where they were advised they would be deported. Mr Love was to be deported to Papua New Guinea, and Mr Thoms was to be deported to New Zealand. Mr Love was released in September 2018 shortly after the present court proceedings were filed. Mr Thoms remains in immigration detention.
Maurice Blackburn Senior Associate Claire Gibbs, who is acting for Mr Love and Mr Thoms, said the case was important in seeking to make clear that it was unacceptable, under the Constitution, for people who were clearly Australians to be subjected to the alien deportation powers.
"In our view it is morally wrong for the Commonwealth to try to remove our clients from Australia, when it is evident that, on any common sense measure, our clients are Australians," Ms Gibbs said.
"Our case is directed to showing that it is also unlawful.
"Our clients have a clear Aboriginal lineage, they each have an Aboriginal Australian parent, they have children who are Aboriginal Australians and they went to school and worked in Australia.
"One of Mr Love's grandfathers, an Aboriginal Australian man, fought for Australia in World War Two. Mr Thoms is a native title holder.
"It defies logic that our clients who came here as kids, whose Aboriginality and strong connection to Australia is not in dispute, should have ever been placed in immigration detention and threatened with removal from Australia.
"No one is seeking to defend the criminal behaviour of our clients. But, in their situation, the fact is they are now being punished twice.  These men have served their time and instead of being released they were instead sent to immigration detention with the threat of deportation. This is not consonant with their multi-layered connections to Australia.
"The case is not challenging the Commonwealth's powers, in the appropriate case, to deport at their discretion people who meet the definition of an alien and have committed a criminal offence.
"Rather, the importance of this case stems from the fact that it addresses the constitutional limits of the 'aliens' power in the Constitution and the threshold question of whether an Aboriginal Australian, born overseas to an Australian Aboriginal parent can, lawfully, be treated as an alien and subjected to those same deportation powers.
"The case argues that they cannot be treated in this way.
"This is an important point for which the need to be clarified extends more widely, as we know there are other Aboriginal Australians in a similar position to our clients," she said.
Mr Love and Mr Thoms are being represented in this social justice matter by Maurice Blackburn Lawyers and the Refugee and Immigration Legal Service (RAILS). Both Mr Love and Mr Thoms are also making a claim in the High Court for unlawful imprisonment.

Maurice Blackburn Lawyers :
76 Wises Road, Maroochydore
07 5430 8700
07 5443 6711
Maurice Blackburn Lawyers
Showing 10+ recent articles for this business
Lawyers welcome lifting deeds of release for abuse survivors 14 June 2019 | As the Royal Commission made clear, many survivors of historical abuse were forced to accept completely inadequate settlements from major institutions and sign deeds as part of this that saw them having to waive... More information...
Maurice Blackburn seeks super fees redress from AMP 02 May 2019 | Australia's largest class action law firm, Maurice Blackburn Lawyers, has today filed the first class action seeking compensation for AMP superannuation fund members allegedly stung by unreasonable fees. The case... More information...
Landmark High Court trial to test if Constitutional 'aliens' power applies to Aboriginal Australians 07 May 2019 | Tomorrow a landmark trial will be held in the High Court of Australia to determine an important threshold question as to whether Aboriginal Australians can be considered an 'alien' under the Constitution and, as a... More information...
Uber set for epic Supreme Court showdown as class action is filed 03 May 2019 | Global ridesharing giant Uber will face potentially one of Australia's biggest class actions, as thousands of taxi, hire car, charter vehicle and limousine drivers and licence owners across the country join forces... More information...
New research: more than half of Australians have no Will, many in the dark about what happens without a Will 09 April 2019 | More than half of Australians do not have a Will and of those, almost 40% have no idea what happens to their assets in the event they pass away without a Will, according to new research commissioned by Maurice... More information...
Lendlease to face shareholder class action investigation 04 April 2019 | Construction giant Lendlease Group (LLC) is set to face fresh legal claims it breached the Corporations Act by failing to properly inform the market of serious problems in its Engineering and Services Business... More information...
Parliamentary report delivers scathing indictment on national redress scheme and must be acted on 03 April 2019 | Lawyers for abuse survivors have welcomed a parliamentary committee report released overnight, with the report a scathing indictment of the national redress scheme that calls for major amendments to ensure the... More information...
First banking class action post Royal Commission filed 21 February 2019 | The first class action against a big four bank since the publication of the Hayne Royal Commission Report has been filed today in the Federal Court, with Australia's leading class action law firm Maurice Blackburn... More information...
MediVac bill to ensure timely medical treatment for refugees and asylum seekers in offshore detention 12 February 2019 | Social justice law firm Maurice Blackburn has tonight welcomed the passing of a bill in the House of Representatives to get sick people out of offshore detention for medical assessment and treatment in Australi... More information...
AWU raids trial set to get underway tomorrow in the Federal Court 09 February 2019 | The case is being run by Maurice Blackburn Lawyers, who are acting on behalf of the AWU, and was brought following unprecedented Australian Federal Police (AFP) raids on the union's headquarters, which were... More information...

comments powered by Disqus

All articles submitted by third parties or written by My Sunshine Coast come under our Disclaimer / Terms of Service