New research finds cancelling superannuation increase would not boost wages

Published:

NOTE: This article is older than 12 months

The onus must lie on those pushing for a super freeze to prove beyond reasonable doubt that snatching a guaranteed remuneration boost from millions will result in an equivalent wage boost. We could not identify any evidence.

A new report to be launched by the McKell Institute today finds no evidence that increasing the super guarantee, from 9.5 per cent to 12 per cent, would cause take-home wages to drop.

The research was prompted by the Grattan Institute's well-publicised claim that "$20 billion" would come out of Australian take-home wages if the superannuation guarantee was increased as scheduled. Grattan's assumption is that every extra dollar paid by an employer into an employee's super would be a dollar withheld from a potential wage increase.

The new report finds no evidence to support Grattan's claim, which has been cited by several Liberal MPs agitating for the federal government to drop its scheduled super increase.

"Grattan's neat one-for-one tradeoff assumption is at odds with conventional economic theory, so our team wanted to see if historic data provided any evidence for the claim. We found none," said McKell Institute Victoria executive director James Pawluk.

"If Grattan's direct tradeoff theory were correct you'd see some sort of historic correlation over the past 30 years between super guarantee rises and trend-breaking wage dips. No matter what labour market data you use, and how hard you dig, no such correlation exists.

"This is consistent with what you would expect. In real world conditions you would assume extra costs on employers to be passed on and absorbed in a range of ways. What actual boss would respond to a mandated super guarantee increase by very carefully removing that exact same amount from their employees' future wage rise? The actual world just doesn't work that way.

"Frankly, it's irresponsible to use a completely unfounded assumption as a starting point for back-of-a-beer-coaster arithmetic. That $20 billion figure was erroneously derived for a headline and it should be discarded from the public discussion."

Mr Pawluk said the slow economy and stagnant wage growth actually added impetus to raising the super guarantee.

"The only direct lever Josh Frydenberg has that will mandate a hard increase in the remuneration of millions overnight is the super guarantee increase," Mr Pawluk said.

"Given the current economic conditions, anyone arguing for a significant transfer of money from employers to employees to be cancelled is making a monumental call.

"The onus must lie on those pushing for a super freeze to prove beyond reasonable doubt that snatching a guaranteed remuneration boost from millions will result in an equivalent wage boost. We could not identify any evidence."

Read the new report here

 
Business Business & Economy Employment & Training Money & Finance
Social:   

Privately Submitted Article or Event :
See Above Article or Event for Address, Sunshine Coast Wide
Privately Submitted Article or Event
Showing 10+ recent articles for this business
How Queensland farmers can prosper in a net-zero emissions world 22 September 2020 | Queensland primary producers looking to strengthen their businesses and communities are encouraged to apply for a new Queensland Resilient Regions Fellowship and masterclass, hosted by Farmers for Climate Action... More information...
Your Help Needed to Extend the Evictions Moratorium 22 September 2020 | As you are probably aware the Queensland Government recently announced their intent to end the evictions moratorium for COVID-19 affected residential renters on 29/9/2020. At the same time, the government have... More information...
Government Policy on JobSeeker and JobKeeper Unhealthy and Economically Counterproductive 21 September 2020 | "The Federal Government's plan to reduce JobSeeker and JobKeeper, its previous elimination of the temporary child care support measures, and its planned tax cuts will damage the lives of many and will have little... More information...
Fleetwood Challenge Cup equips next generation of built design professionals to solve Australia's housing affordability challenge 18 September 2020 | An Australian-first inter-University design competition saw Architecture, Engineering and Construction (AEC) students team up to face the challenge and deliver industry leading built environment design solutions... More information...
Future technologists battle it out at RoboRave challenge 18 September 2020 | RoboRAVE Australia 2020, will see over one hundred teams compete in a series of robotics challenges that test their skills in coding and mechatronics. This ground breaking event opens its doors to registered... More information...
AFPFMA calls on Government to adopt the term 'Police Veteran'' 21 September 2020 | The Australian Federal Police Former Members Association (AFPFMA) has called on the Federal Government to start using the term ‘police veteran’ when referring to former police. More information...
Telehealth expansion welcomed by rural health peak body 18 September 2020 | The National Rural Health Alliance, the peak body for rural health in Australia, welcomed the Australian Government's expansion of Medicare rebates for telehealth consultations until 31 March 2021. More information...
Accountants again under pressure to implement Jobkeeper 2.0 16 September 2020 | The release of the legislative rules for JobKeeper 2.0 yesterday highlights yet again the vital role accountants are playing during the COVID-19 emergency in helping Australians and businesses access the extended... More information...
Consultation Paper on the Pricing Framework for Australian Public Hospital Services 2021–22 released for public comment 09 September 2020 | The Independent Hospital Pricing Authority (IHPA) today released its Consultation Paper on the Pricing Framework for Australian Public Hospital Services 2021–22. More information...
Why it is cheaper to buy in southeast Queensland than to rent 09 September 2020 | Areas such as the Sunshine Coast and Gold Coast have enjoyed exceptional capital growth over the past 10 years with further positive projections in the medium to long term, especially as more and more people work... More information...


comments powered by Disqus

All articles submitted by third parties or written by My Sunshine Coast come under our Disclaimer / Terms of Service